Non-defining Relative Clauses
Add extra information with commas
Introduction to Non-defining Relative Clauses
Non-defining relative clauses (also called non-restrictive clauses) add extra information about a noun that is already clearly identified. Unlike defining clauses, they do not restrict or limit the meaning of the noun. These clauses are always set off by commas and cannot be removed without changing the sentence structure, though the core meaning remains intact.
Defining vs Non-defining Clauses: Key Differences
Comma Usage Rules in Non-defining Clauses
The man who called is my uncle. (who for people).
Who refers to people in relative clauses.
The book which I bought is interesting. (which for things).
Which/that refers to things.
The girl whose project won is my friend. (whose = possession).
Whose shows possession in relative clauses.
Relative Pronouns in Non-defining Clauses
Non-defining clauses use specific relative pronouns depending on what they refer to. The most common are which (for things), who (for people), where (for places), and when (for times). Remember: "that" cannot be used in non-defining clauses.
- which - for things, animals, or entire clauses: "The report, which took three hours to write, was approved."
- who - for people: "Dr. Sharma, who teaches at IIT, won the award."
- whom - for people as objects (formal): "The minister, whom we met yesterday, announced the policy."
- whose - for possession: "My colleague, whose son studies at Harvard, is retiring."
- where - for places: "Mumbai, where I was born, is a coastal city."
- when - for times: "December, when it gets very cold, is my favorite month."
which: The Indian Constitution, which is the longest written constitution, has 448 articles.
Adds extra fact about the Constitution.
who: Mahatma Gandhi, who led the independence movement, believed in non-violence.
Additional information about a well-known person.
where: The Red Fort, where the Prime Minister hoists the flag on August 15, is in Delhi.
Place already identified, adding context.
Special Use: 'Which' Referring to an Entire Clause
The man who called is my uncle. (who for people).
Who refers to people in relative clauses.
The book which I bought is interesting. (which for things).
Which/that refers to things.
The girl whose project won is my friend. (whose = possession).
Whose shows possession in relative clauses.
Common Mistakes with Non-defining Clauses
Here are the most common mistakes and how to correct them:
- Missing commas: Wrong - "My father who is a teacher retired." Correct - "My father, who is a teacher, retired."
- Using "that" instead of "which": Wrong - "The book, that I read, was good." Correct - "The book, which I read, was good."
- Missing second comma: Wrong - "Delhi, which is the capital is crowded." Correct - "Delhi, which is the capital, is crowded."
- Mixing defining and non-defining: Wrong - "Students, who study hard succeed." (This suggests all students study hard)
- Omitting relative pronoun: Wrong - "My brother, lives in USA, is visiting." Correct - "My brother, who lives in USA, is visiting."
- Using "whom" incorrectly: Wrong - "The girl, whom is smart, won." Correct - "The girl, who is smart, won." (subject, not object)
- Comma placement with names: Wrong - "My friend Ravi who is a doctor..." Correct - "My friend Ravi, who is a doctor..."
- Double commas in speech: Wrong - "He said, that, the plan, which was new, worked." (too many commas)
Indian Context Examples: 15+ Authentic Sentences
Here are 15+ authentic examples using Indian contexts, names, and situations relevant to:
Dr. APJ Abdul Kalam, who was known as the Missile Man, served as President from 2002 to 2007.
Famous person with additional biographical detail.
The Ganges, which Hindus consider sacred, flows through several northern states.
River with religious context.
Mumbai, where Bollywood is based, is India's financial capital.
City with industry information.
The monsoon season, which lasts from June to September, is crucial for agriculture.
Time period with significance.
IIT Delhi, whose graduates work worldwide, ranks among Asia's top universities.
Institution with achievements.
My neighbor Rajesh, who works at Infosys, recently got promoted.
Person with workplace detail.
The Supreme Court, which is located in New Delhi, has 34 judges.
Institution with factual information.
Diwali, when families celebrate with lights and sweets, falls in October or November.
Festival with traditional practices.
The Indian Railways, which employs over 1.3 million people, is one of the world's largest networks.
Organization with statistics.
Kerala, where literacy rates exceed 95%, is known as "God's Own Country.".
State with educational achievement.
My cousin Priya, whom you met last year, has moved to Bangalore.
Personal connection with update.
The RBI, which regulates banks, recently changed interest rates.
context (relevant for / exams).
Hindi, which is spoken by over 40% of Indians, is written in Devanagari script.
Language with demographic data.
January 26, when we celebrate Republic Day, is a national holiday.
Date with patriotic significance.
The Himalayas, which form India's northern border, contain the world's highest peaks.
Geography with superlative.
Practice Exercises: Sentence Combination
Combine these sentences: Dr Ramesh is a cardiologist. | He works at Apollo Hospital.
Answer: Dr Ramesh, who is a cardiologist, works at Apollo Hospital.
Use 'who' for person (subject). Name requires non-defining clause with commas.
Combine these sentences: The Taj Mahal was built by Shah Jahan. | It is one of the Seven Wonders.
Answer: The Taj Mahal, which was built by Shah Jahan, is one of the Seven Wonders.
Use 'which' for thing. Proper noun (Taj Mahal) needs commas.
Combine these sentences: My sister lives in London. | I visited her last month.
Answer: My sister, whom I visited last month, lives in London.
Use 'whom' for person (object: I visited her). If one sister, use commas.
Combine these sentences: Professor Gupta teaches economics. | His lectures are very popular.
Answer: Professor Gupta, whose lectures are very popular, teaches economics.
Use 'whose' for possession (his lectures). Name needs commas.
Combine these sentences: Bangalore is known as India's Silicon Valley. | Many IT companies are located there.
Answer: Bangalore, where many IT companies are located, is known as India's Silicon Valley.
Use 'where' for place. City name requires non-defining clause with commas.
Combine these sentences: I graduated in 2019. | The pandemic started the following year.
Answer: I graduated in 2019, when the pandemic started the following year.
Use 'when' for time. Specific year (2019) needs comma before clause.
Combine these sentences: She scored 95% in her exams. | This surprised everyone.
Answer: She scored 95% in her exams, which surprised everyone.
'Which' refers to entire clause (her scoring 95%). Comma required.
Combine these sentences: The Indian Constitution was adopted on 26 January 1950. | It is the supreme law of the land.
Answer: The Indian Constitution, which was adopted on 26 January 1950, is the supreme law of the land.
Proper noun (Constitution) with 'which' for thing. Commas required.
Combine these sentences: My father is a retired teacher. | His advice I always follow.
Answer: My father, whose advice I always follow, is a retired teacher.
'Whose' shows possession (his advice). 'My father' (unique) needs commas.
Combine these sentences: The monsoon arrived early this year. | This was beneficial for farmers.
Answer: The monsoon arrived early this year, which was beneficial for farmers.
'Which' refers to entire situation (early arrival). Comma before 'which'.
Students who study regularly perform better in exams.
Answer: No commas needed - this is a defining clause.
Identifies which students (those who study regularly). Essential information.
My brother who lives in Chennai is a software engineer.
Answer: My brother, who lives in Chennai, is a software engineer. (if you have one brother).
If one brother, 'my brother' is unique. Clause is non-defining; needs commas.
The Gateway of India which is in Mumbai is an iconic monument.
Answer: The Gateway of India, which is in Mumbai, is an iconic monument.
Proper noun (Gateway of India) requires commas for non-defining clause.
The book which is on the table belongs to me.
Answer: No commas needed - this is a defining clause.
Identifies which book (the one on the table, not elsewhere). Defining.
Dr Kalam who was a great scientist inspired millions.
Answer: Dr Kalam, who was a great scientist, inspired millions.
Proper noun (Dr Kalam) requires commas for non-defining clause.
Mumbai, that is India's financial capital, has a large population.
Answer: Mumbai, which is India's financial capital, has a large population.
'That' cannot be used in non-defining clauses. Use 'which' for things.
My teacher who taught me mathematics has retired.
Answer: My teacher, who taught me mathematics, has retired.
If referring to one specific teacher, use commas for non-defining clause.
The project, I completed last week, was approved.
Answer: The project, which I completed last week, was approved.
Relative pronoun 'which' cannot be omitted in non-defining clauses.
Professor Singh, who research is famous, won an award.
Answer: Professor Singh, whose research is famous, won an award.
Use 'whose' to show possession before a noun (his research).
She passed the exam which surprised everyone.
Answer: She passed the exam, which surprised everyone.
When 'which' refers to entire clause, comma is required.
Quick Revision: Key Points to Remember
- Non-defining clauses provide extra information about already identified nouns
- ALWAYS use commas: before and after (middle position) or before (end position)
- NEVER use 'that' in non-defining clauses - use who, which, whose, where, when
- Proper nouns (names) almost always take non-defining clauses with commas
- Use 'who' for people (subject), 'whom' for people (object), 'whose' for possession
- Use 'which' for things; can also refer to entire preceding clause
- 'Which' for whole clause = comma + which + verb (singular) - means 'and this'
- Cannot omit relative pronouns in non-defining clauses (unlike defining clauses)
- Test: Can you remove the clause without changing core meaning? If yes, use commas
- Missing commas changes meaning from extra information to essential identification
Noun, + which/who/where + clause, + main clause continues
Practise Non-defining Relative Clauses
Create a free account for interactive lessons, quizzes and progress tracking across all English topics.